Publications, Presentations, Reports and Manuscripts
Nicholas G. Smedira, MD, Eugene H. Blackstone, MD, John Ehrlinger, PhD, Lucy Thuita, MS, Christopher D. Pierce, PhD, Nader Moazami, MD, and Randall C. Starling, MD, MPH
2015 Current risks of HeartMate II pump thrombosis: Non-parametric analysis of Interagency Registry for Mechanically Assisted Circulatory Support data. The Journal of Heart and Lung Transplantation Vol 34, No 12:1527-1534.
View/hide abstract- Download PDF reprint
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Data from 3 institutions revealed an abrupt increase in HeartMate II (Thoratec) pumpthrombosis starting in 2011, associated with 48% mortality at 6 months without transplantation or pumpexchange. We sought to discover if the increase occurred nationwide in Interagency Registry for Mechanically Assisted Circulatory Support (INTERMACS) data, and if so (1) determine if acceleratedrisk continued, (2) identify predictors, (3) investigate institutional variability, and (4) assess mortalityafter pump thrombosis.
METHODS: From April 2008 to June 2014, 11,123 HeartMate II devices were implanted at 146institutions. Machine learning, non-parametric Random Forests for Survival was used to explore risk-adjusted thrombosis based on 87 pre-implant and implant variables, including implant date.
RESULTS: A total of 995 pumps thrombosed, with risk peaking within weeks of implant. The risk-adjusted increase in pump thrombosis began in 2010, reached a maximum in 2012, and then plateaued at a level that was 3.3-times higher than pre-2010. Pump exchange, younger age, and larger body massindex were important predictors, and institutional variability was largely explained by implant date,patient profile, and duration of support. The probability of death within 3 months after pump thrombosis was 24%.
CONCLUSIONS: Accelerated risk of HeartMate II thrombosis was confirmed by Interagency Registryfor Mechanically Assisted Circulatory Support data, with risk subsequently leveling at a risk-adjusted rate higher than observed pre-2010. This elevated thrombosis risk emphasizes the need for improved mechanical circulatory support systems and post-market surveillance of adverse events.Clinicians cognizant of these new data should incorporate them into their and their patients’expectations and understanding of risks relative to those of transplantation and continued medicaltherapy.
KEYWORDS: HeartMate II;pump thrombosis;INTERMACS;mortality;regulatory;left ventricular assist device (LVAD)
Pierce, Christopher D., David Booth, Chimezie Ogbuji, Chris
Deaton, Eugene Blackstone and Doug Lenat
2012 SemanticDB: A Semantic Web Infrastructure for
Clinical Research and Quality Reporting. Current
Bioinformatics 7(3):267-277.
View/hide abstract - Download PDF reprint
Abstract
Semantic Web technologies offer the potential to revolutionize management of health care data by increasing its interoperability and reusability while reducing the need for redundant data collection and storage. From 1998 through 2010, Cleveland Clinic sponsored a project designed to explore and develop this potential. The product of this effort, SemanticDB, is a suite of software tools and knowledge resources built to facilitate the collection, storage and use of the diverse data needed to conduct clinical research and health care quality reporting.
SemanticDB consists of three main components: 1) a content repository driven by a meta-model that facilitates collection and integration of data in an XML format and automatically converts the data to RDF; 2) an inference-mediated, natural language query interface designed to identify patients who meet complex inclusion and exclusion criteria; and 3) a data production pipeline that uses inference to generate customized views of the repository content for statistical analysis and reporting. Since 2008, this system has been used by the Cleveland Clinic's Heart and Vascular Institute to support numerous clinical investigations, and in 2009 Cleveland Clinic was certified to submit data produced in this manner to national quality monitoring databases sponsored by the Society of Thoracic Surgeons and the American College of Cardiology.
Keywords: clinical data, electronic medical records, inference, ontology, clinical research, quality reporting, RDF, Semantic Web
Booth, David and Christopher Pierce
2011 RDF Data Pipelines for Semantic Data Federation.
7th Annual Semantic Technology Conference, San Francisco, Ca. March 8.
View/hide abstract - Download PDF version
Abstract
Experience in applying semantic web technology to clinical health care research has revealed the need for a more consistent approach to RDF data production.
Data originating in diverse clinical systems, formats and data models typically must be transformed to hub ontologies, merged, inferenced, selected and finally transformed to consuming applications' ontologies and data formats for productive use. The process is quite repetitive: similar transformations are often performed each day, week or month with only slight variations to the data windows and queries. Ad hoc data production scripts can be created to help automate this process, but they tend to be fragile, inefficient, difficult to maintain and hard to visualize.
This presentation describes a simple framework and ontology for cached RDF data production pipelines, based on RESTful HTTP and SPARQL. These pipelines are easily visualized, and incremental data changes automatically propagate through to consuming applications.
Pierce, Christopher
2010 Healthcare Quality Reporting with Semantic Technologies.
Cleveland Clinic Medical Informatics Grand Rounds, Cleveland Oh. August
20.
View/hide abstract - Download PowerPoint presentation
Abstract
Hospitals have come under increasing pressure to report a wide variety of health care process and outcomes measures to various governmental and non-governmental agencies. Typically, the data needed for these reports are captured in separate, unconnected databases designed to fulfill the specific requirements of individual agencies. Although initially expedient, this approach to quality reporting has several drawbacks: 1) it can result in costly redundant data collection if different reports have overlapping requirements; 2) similar data collected in separate databases can produce discrepancies in the same measures reported to different agencies; 3) data targeting specific quality reports often are difficult to use for other purposes, such as clinical research; and 4) the particular data collected are subject to the changing requirements of individual agencies, making multi-year comparisons difficult.
To overcome these problems, Cleveland Clinic's Heart and Vascular Institute has adopted a semantic approach to quality reporting, which uses ontology and rule-based inference to derive specific reported values from core clinical facts collected in a common RDF data repository. We use SemanticDB to collect core clinical data for individual patients through feeds from other clinical systems, and manual, forms-based data entry. These core patient medical data are stored in named RDF graphs, which can be expanded through a combination of forward and backward inference to include new classes useful for generating specific quality reports. These reports are generated with an application built on the Cyc ontology and reasoner that align logical and physical schemas, formulate appropriate SPARQL queries of the expanded graphs, and transform results to the required format. With this approach, core clinical data can be collected in a highly reusable form with little or no redundancy. In addition, differences or changes in reporting requirements can often be handled by modifications of the ontologies and rules guiding the inferential expansion of patient graphs and SPARQL queries rather than the actual data collected.
Pierce, Christopher D., David Booth, Chris Deaton and Chimezie
Ogbuji
2010 Meaningful Use of Electronic Medical Records through
Semantic Technologies: The Cleveland Clinic Experience. 6th
Annual Semantic Technology Conference, San Francisco, Ca. June 25.
View/hide abstract - Download PowerPoint presentation
Abstract
Medical records come in many forms including enterprise-wide electronic health records mandated by the 2009 federal stimulus package, lab and clinic-based data management systems, administrative databases for scheduling, billing and inventory control, and secondary databases for clinical research and quality reporting. Making meaningful use of these disparate data sources to improve the cost and quality of patient care turns on our ability to accurately model their complex semantics and exploit these semantics through machine processing.
Since 2003, Cleveland Clinic has applied semantic technologies to making use of diverse data derived from the treatment of over 200,000 patients with cardiovascular disease over the past 30 years. This presentation outlines the practical issues and challenges faced, and describes how some of these issues have been overcome while others remain unsolved. Topics covered include:
- domain ontology development and utilization
- linking domain ontologies to specific instance data models
- data definition, validation and aggregation
- data utilization for health care quality analysis and reporting
Pierce, Christopher, David Booth and Chris Deaton
2010 Making Meaningful Use of Electronic Medical Records at
Cleveland Clinic. Cambridge Semantic Web Interest Group
Meeting, Cambridge, Ma. May 11.
View/hide abstract - Download PowerPoint presentation
Abstract
Medical records come in many forms including enterprise-wide electronic health records mandated by the 2009 federal stimulus package, lab and clinic-based data management systems, administrative databases for scheduling, billing and inventory control, and secondary databases for clinical research and quality reporting. Making meaningful use of these disparate data sources to improve the cost and quality of patient care turns on our ability to accurately model their complex semantics and exploit these semantics through machine processing.
Since 2003, Cleveland Clinic has applied semantic technologies to making use of diverse data derived from the treatment of over 200,000 patients with cardiovascular disease over the past 30 years. This presentation outlines the practical issues and challenges faced, and describes how some of these issues have been overcome while others remain unsolved. Topics covered include:
- domain ontology development and utilization
- linking domain ontologies to specific instance data models
- data definition, validation and aggregation
- data utilization for health care quality analysis and reporting
Ogbuji, Chimezie, Christopher Pierce and Chris Deaton
2009 Semantic Web Technologies as a Framework for Clinical
Informatics. 5th Annual Semantic Technology Conference, San
Jose, Ca. June 16.
View/hide abstract - View PowerPoint presentation
Abstract
The ability to identify patient populations for clinical research according to specific criteria is a critical component of clinical informatics. Traditionally, database systems that leverage relational databases are used to store and manage the data targeted for population identification. The process of starting with an abstract research question (posed in prose) and distilling it into the specific query plans and corresponding data structures necessary to answer such research questions is often significantly tedious and primarily driven by idiosyncrasies of how the data is stored rather than the underlying science that guides the intuition of the researcher. Contemporary clinical data management systems have yet to move beyond this approach.
Cleveland Clinic and Cycorp Inc. have developed a state-of-the-art query interface that builds query fragments through natural language-driven interactions with an investigator. This interface targets a clinical research repository comprised of patient record content expressed in an RDF dataset that conforms to a patient record OWL ontology and is queried over the SPARQL service protocol. It leverages the Cyc common sense ontology, Cyc's natural language processing capabilities, formalized mappings from the common sense ontology into the patient record ontology, and the availability of a SPARQL service for querying the patient population.
In this session, we describe the specifics of this framework, enumerate its strengths and weaknesses, and derive insights into the opportunities and challenges of adopting Semantic Web Technologies for the purpose of managing and identifying patient populations.
Pierce, Christopher, Chris Deaton, Brian Beck and Chimezie
Ogbuji
2009 A Semantic Approach to Health Care Quality Reporting.
5th Annual Semantic Technology Conference, San Jose, Ca. June 15.
View/hide abstract - Download PowerPoint presentation
Abstract
Hospitals have come under increasing pressure to report a wide variety of health care process and outcomes measures to various governmental and non-governmental agencies. Typically, the data needed for these reports are captured in separate, unconnected databases designed to fulfill the specific requirements of individual agencies. Although initially expedient, this approach to quality reporting has several drawbacks: 1) it can result in costly redundant data collection if different reports have overlapping requirements; 2) similar data collected in separate databases can produce discrepancies in the same measures reported to different agencies; 3) data targeting specific quality reports often are difficult to use for other purposes, such as clinical research; and 4) the particular data collected are subject to the changing requirements of individual agencies, making multi-year comparisons difficult.
To overcome these problems, Cleveland Clinic's Heart and Vascular Institute has adopted a semantic approach to quality reporting, which uses ontology and rule-based inference to derive specific reported values from core clinical facts collected in a common RDF data repository. We use SemanticDB to collect core clinical data for individual patients through feeds from other clinical systems, and manual, forms-based data entry. These core patient medical data are stored in named RDF graphs, which can be expanded through a combination of forward and backward inference to include new classes useful for generating specific quality reports. These reports are generated with an application built on the Cyc ontology and reasoner that align logical and physical schemas, formulate appropriate SPARQL queries of the expanded graphs, and transform results to the required format. With this approach, core clinical data can be collected in a highly reusable form with little or no redundancy. In addition, differences or changes in reporting requirements can often be handled by modifications of the ontologies and rules guiding the inferential expansion of patient graphs and SPARQL queries rather than the actual data collected.
Ramenofsky, Ann F., Fraser D. Neiman and Christopher D. Pierce
2008 Measuring Time, Population, and Residential Mobility
from the Surface at San Marcos Pueblo, North Central New Mexico.
American Antiquity Volume 74, Number 3, pp. 505-530
View/hide abstract - View HTML version - Download PDF preprint
Abstract
To understand the effects of European contact on the organization, size, and mobility of Pueblo populations in the Southwest requires detailed knowledge of the occupational histories of the aggregated settlements that typify the late prehistoric and early historic record. Unfortunately, such understanding is generally lacking because the methods used to document occupational histories of settlements tend to either obscure fine- grained temporal distinctions or necessitate costly, and politically objectionable, large- scale excavations. To overcome these difficulties, we use surface expressions to analyze the occupational and population history of San Marcos Pueblo (LA98), an aggregated, late prehistoric site in the Galisteo Basin of New Mexico that persisted to the Pueblo Revolt of 1680. Field methods include detailed mapping of the settlement and systematic surface collections of middens. Frequency seriation, correspondence analysis, and mean ceramic dates of decorated ceramic rims comprise our principal analytic methods and demonstrate that the pueblo was abandoned four times before 1680. Causes of abandonment are discussed. Relative scale measures of population show demographic fluctuations with maximum aggregation during the fifteenth century. Despite demographic pulses, the pueblo remained vital until the terminal abandonment.
Ogbuji, Chimezie, Eugene Blackstone, Chris Pierce
2007 Case Study: A Semantic Web Content Repository for
Clinical Research. W3C Semantic Web Use Cases and Case
Studies. Available at: http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/sweo/public/UseCases/ClevelandClinic/.
Pierce, Christopher and Chimezie Ogbuji
2007 An Application of Semantic Technologies to Computerized
Patient Medical Records. Invited presentation, 3rd Annual
World Healthcare Innovation and Technology Congress, Washington, D.C.
December 10.
Pierce, Christopher and Chimezie Ogbuji
2007 Semantic Integration of Clinical Data for Outcomes
Research and Reporting. Clinical Research Informatics Expo,
American Medical Informatics Association Annual Meeting, Chicago, Il.
November 10-14.
Pierce, Christopher, Chimezie Ogbuji, Sivaram Arabandi and
John Clark
2007 Semantic Technology and Computer-Based Patient Records.
3rd Annual Semantic Technology Conference, San Jose, CA. May 23.
Roselli, Eric E., Sudish C. Murthy, Thomas W. Rice, Penny L.
Houghtaling, Christopher D. Pierce, Daniel P. Karchmer and Eugene H.
Blackstone
2005 Atrial Fibrillation Complicating Lung Cancer Resection.
Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery
130:438-444.
View/hide abstract - Link to journal
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To (1) characterize atrial fibrillation complicating lung cancer resection, (2) evaluate its temporal relationship to other postoperative complications, and (3) assess its economics.
METHODS: From January 1998 to August 2002, 604 patients underwent anatomic lung cancer resection. Atrial fibrillation prevalence, onset, and temporal associations with other postoperative complications were determined. Propensity matching was used to assess economics.
RESULTS: Atrial fibrillation occurred in 113 patients (19%), peaking on postoperative day 2. Older age, male gender, heart failure, clamshell incision, and right pneumonectomy were risk factors (P < .01). Although atrial fibrillation was solitary in 75 patients (66%), other postoperative complications occurred in 38. Respiratory and infectious complications were temporally linked with atrial fibrillation onset. In 91 propensity-matched pairs, patients developing atrial fibrillation had more other postoperative complications (30% vs. 9%, P < .0004), had longer postoperative stays (median 8 vs 5 days, P < .0001), incurred higher costs (cost ratio 1.8, 68% confidence limits 1.6-2.1), and had higher in-hospital mortality (8% vs 0%, P = .01). Even when atrial fibrillation was a solitary complication, hospital stay was longer (median 7 vs 5 days, P < .0001), and cost was higher (cost ratio 1.5, 68% confidence limits 1.2-1.6).
CONCLUSION: Atrial fibrillation occurs in 1 in 5 patients after lung cancer resection, with peak onset on postoperative day 2. Risk factors are both patient and procedure related, and atrial fibrillation may herald other serious complications. Although often solitary, atrial fibrillation is associated with longer hospital stay and higher cost. It therefore requires prompt treatment and should stimulate investigation for other problems.
Pierce, Christopher
2005 Reverse Engineering the Ceramic Cooking Pot: Cost and
Performance Properties of Plain and Textured Vessels. Journal
of Archaeological Method and Theory 12(2): 117-157.
View/hide abstract - Download PDF reprint
Abstract
Ceramic cooking pots throughout the world vary in exterior surface treatment from smooth to roughly textured. An intriguing example of this variation occurred in the Puebloan region of the southwestern United States where cooking pots changed from scraped plain to highly textured, corrugated vessels between the seventh and eleventh centuries AD, and then reverted back to plain-surfaced by the fifteenth century. To investigate potential cost and performance differences between plain and corrugated cooking pots, a set of controlled experiments were performed, which document manufacturing costs, cooking effectiveness, and vessel durability. These experiments indicate that while corrugation may have increased manufacturing costs, neck corrugations improved vessel handling, upper body corrugations yielded greater control over cooking, and basal corrugations extended vessel use-life. Discerning the explanatory significance of these results for cooking pot change in the Southwest and elsewhere requires additional data on the contexts in which these pots were made and used.
Keywords
reverse engineering; experimental archaeology; cooking pots; Puebloan southwest
Pierce, Christopher
2005 The Development of Corrugated Pottery in Southwestern
Colorado. Kiva 71(1): 79-100.
View/hide abstract - Download PDF reprint
Abstract
Archaeological research has documented the broad outlines of the development of corrugated utility pottery from plain and neck-banded antecedents. However, a reliance on typological descriptions has obscured the technological details of this development. An attribute analysis of six well-dated utility-ware assemblages from southwestern Colorado indicates that corrugation appeared first in this region during the eighth century A. D. as wide, non-overlapping coils left unsmoothed around jar necks. During the ninth and tenth centuries, the variety and frequency of neck-banding increased with the introduction of narrower coils, overlapping of adjacent coils, and incising and indenting of coil surfaces. By the early eleventh century, one recent neck-banding variant, narrow, substantially overlapped and indented coils, replaced almost all others, and was extended over the entire exterior surface of jars for the first time. Performance benefits of this full-body, indented corrugation may explain its rapid adoption in southwestern Colorado.
Kim, Kwhanmien, Thomas W. Rice, Sudish C. Murthy, Malcolm M.
DeCamp, Christopher D. Pierce, Daniel P. Karchmer, Lisa A. Rybicki and
Eugene H. Blackstone
2004 Combined Bronchoscopy, Mediastinoscopy, and Thoracotomy
for Lung Cancer: Who Benefits? Journal of Thoracic
and Cardiovascular Surgery 127:850-856.
View/hide abstract - Link to journal
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Surgical staging and resection of lung cancer may be done as 1 operation (combined) or 2 (staged). This study evaluates the safety and efficiency of these treatment strategies.
METHODS: From 1998 to July 2001, 343 patients underwent bronchoscopy, mediastinoscopy, and thoracotomy without induction chemoradiotherapy by 3 surgeons. Fifty-seven patients were staged and 286 combined. Staged patients had higher clinical stage (P < .001). Propensity-matched groups were compared to adjust for this and other differences. Factors associated with safety and efficiency were identified by propensity-adjusted multivariable analysis.
RESULTS: Mortality and morbidity were similar for both strategies. Efficiency, measured by shorter operative time (1.2 hours) and lower cost (25%), was better for combined strategy (P < .001). Hospital stay was similar, but revenue was 12% higher for the staged strategy (P < .001). In propensity-matched comparisons excluding surgeon, results were similar to the above. Comparisons including surgeon demonstrated similar cost and revenue for both strategies. Increased mortality and morbidity were associated only with patient and tumor characteristics: male gender, worsening Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group performance status, and increasing pathological node classification. All measures of efficiency worsened with increasing pathological classifications. Staged strategy was associated with increased operative time and revenue, while one surgeon and patient smoking history were associated with increased hospital stay and costs.
CONCLUSIONS: The combined strategy provides efficient, safe health care for clinically operable lung cancer patients, but it may not be as financially rewarding as the staged strategy. Treatment strategy is only 1 of many determinants of efficiency.
Sabik, J. F., J. A. Holmes, A. Boone, J. Feng, C. Pierce, T.
G. Santoscoy, E. H. Blackstone
2003 Effectiveness of Blake vs. Standard Drains for Pleural
Cavity Drainage in Cardiac Surgery: A Randomized Clinical Trial, Final
Report. Department of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery,
Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Cleveland, OH.
Pierce, Christopher, Donna M. Glowacki, and Margaret M. Thurs
2002 Measuring Community Interaction: Pueblo III Pottery
Production and Distribution in the Central Mesa Verde Region.
In Seeking the Center Place: Archaeology and Ancient
Communities in the Mesa Verde Region, edited by M. D. Varien
and R. H. Wilshusen, pp. 185–202. University of Utah Press, Salt Lake
City.
View/hide abstract - View HTML version
Abstract
The scale, intensity, and character of interaction among Pueblo people during the 13th century A.D. likely played an important role in the processes and events leading to the abandonment of the Northern San Juan region in the 1280s. Characteristics of pottery production and distribution in the Sand Canyon locality provide one means of investigating these interactions. Variation among Pueblo III settlements in the use of temper and available raw clay sources, and the distribution of pottery production tools demonstrate the existence of at least two production areas within the locality. The nature of the boundary between these production areas indicates a complex pattern of settlement and community interaction that challenges models based on settlement proximity. Further, an almost complete lack of extra-regional pottery at Pueblo III settlements suggests that the Northern San Juan region may have been economically isolated from other regions inhabited by Pueblo people.
Pierce, Christopher and Ann Ramenofsky
2000 Report on Archaeological Research Conducted at Pueblo
San Marcos (LA98) during 1999 by the University of New Mexico.
Ms. on file, Laboratory of Anthropology, Santa Fe, NM.
Ramenofsky, Ann and Christopher Pierce
1999 A Summary Report on Archaeological Mapping at Pueblo San
Marcos (LA98), 1997 & 1998. Ms. on file, Laboratory
of Anthropology, Museum of New Mexico, Santa Fe, NM.
View HTML version - Download PDF version
Pierce, Christopher
1999 Explaining corrugated pottery in the American
Southwest: an evolutionary approach. Ph.D.
dissertation, Department of Anthropology, University of Washington,
Seattle, Wa.
View/hide abstract - View HTML version- Download PDF version
Abstract
Corrugated pottery is a unique utility ware made by leaving construction coils unobliterated, and manipulating these exposed coils to produce a rough exterior surface. Ancestral Puebloan populations in the American Southwest made this pottery in various forms between AD 650 and 1450. Although archaeologists have tried to explain corrugation for over 100 years, none of these explanations has proven satisfactory. I employ an evolutionary approach in an attempt to explain the rise and fall of corrugated pottery.
Using analyses of ancient pottery, experiments with modern replicas, and syntheses of published data, I document that corrugation developed gradually from plain ware through a series of innovations in the size of coils and how they were applied and manipulated. Initially, corrugation appeared in the southern Mogollon region as wide, filleted, and unindented bands on jar necks, and spread north into the Anasazi areas of the Colorado Plateau. The development of overlapped and indented neck bands during the ninth and tenth centuries ultimately led to the use of these techniques over the entire exterior surface during the eleventh century producing full-body, indented corrugation. Full-body corrugation spread rapidly across a large area of the Colorado Plateau, and remained dominant until the fifteenth century when a return to plain pottery occurred. The development of corrugation coincided with an increase in the use of these vessels to cook food.
Although most of the innovations appeared first as decorative elaborations, some also affected the cost and performance of the vessels. The use of narrower and overlapped coils increased the time required to form a vessel over the earlier plain vessels. However, the extension of the textured surface to the upper body and basal parts of vessels significantly improved control over cooking and the use-life of vessels respectively.
Explanations of corrugation emphasize how the environment with which corrugated pottery interacted changed through time, and how these changes affected innovation rates, and the selection or drift of particular corrugation variants. In formulating explanations, I address four problems: the advent of neck banding, experimentation with neck banding, the rapid adoption of full-body corrugation, and the return to plain-surfaced pottery.
Pierce, Christopher, Mark D. Varien, John C. Driver, G. T.
Gross and Joseph W. Keleher
1999 Artifacts. In The Sand Canyon
Archaeological Project: Site Testing, edited by M. D. Varien,
Chapter 15. CD-ROM, Vers. 1.0. Crow Canyon Archaeological Center,
Cortez, Colorado. Distributed by University of Arizona Press and
available at: http://www.crowcanyon.org/sitetesting.
Pierce, Christopher and Joseph W. Keleher
1999 Cores and Debitage. In The Sand
Canyon Archaeological Project: Site Testing, edited by M. D.
Varien, section in Chapter 15. Distributed by University of Arizona
Press and available at: http://www.crowcanyon.org/sitetesting.
Pierce, Christopher and Mark D. Varien
1999 Pottery. In The Sand Canyon
Archaeological Project: Site Testing, edited by M. D. Varien,
section in Chapter 15. CD-ROM, Vers. 1.0. Crow Canyon Archaeological
Center, Cortez, Colorado. Distributed by University of Arizona Press
and available at: http://www.crowcanyon.org/sitetesting.
Pierce, Christopher
1999 Stone Tools and Manufacturing Debris. In The
Sand Canyon Archaeological Project: Site Testing Program,
edited by M. D. Varien. Crow Canyon Archaeological Center, Cortez, Co.
Distributed by University of Arizona Press and available at:
http://www.crowcanyon.org/sitetesting.
Pierce, Christopher
1998 Theory, Measurement, and Explanation: Variable Shapes in
Poverty Point Objects. In Unit Issues in Archaeology,
edited by Ann F. Ramenofsky and Anastasia Steffen, pp.163-190.
University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City.
Pierce, Christopher, Karen Adams and Joe Stewart
1998 Determining the Fuel Constituents of Ancient Hearth Ash
via ICP-AES Analysis. Journal of Archaeological
Science 25:493-503.
View/hide abstract - Download PDF reprint
Abstract
Documenting variation and change in the use of particular plants and plant parts for fuel in ancient households contributes to an understanding of settlement location, local and regional abandonments and resource depletion. Chemical analysis of ash surviving in hearths and other thermal features to determine the kinds and relative amounts of fuels consumed may be less biased by formation processes than the macrofossil record currently employed to document ancient fuel use. Our studies indicate that it is possible to distinguish, chemically, ash of common fuel taxa and tissue types (bark, wood, etc.) in both modern and ancient samples of fuels found in the northern Colorado Plateau region of the American Southwest. However, the chemical signatures of the ancient and modern material of the same taxon differ, indicating possible alteration by post-depositional processes. Although multiple regression performs well in determining the relative contributions of different fuels to modern ash mixtures, possible post-depositional alterations and incomplete characterization of the range of within-taxon variation, currently limit our confidence in applications of this approach to ancient ash from Pueblo III settlements in south-west Colorado.
Pierce, Christopher
1998 Toward Explaining Complex Patterns of Human Cooperation
and Conflict. Invited presentation to workshop on "Modeling
Complexity in Social Systems," Colorado Center for Chaos and
Complexity, University of Colorado, Boulder.
Pierce, Christopher
1998 Explaining the Rise and Fall of Corrugated Cooking Pots
in the American Southwest. Invited presentation, 63rd Annual
Meeting of the Society for American Archaeology, Seattle, Wa.
Penman, S., A. Ramenofsky, C. Pierce, D. Vaughan, and E. Welker
1998 Will the Real San Marcos Pueblo Please Stand Up? An
Examination of Bias and Error in Archaeological Site Maps.
63rd Annual Meeting of the Society for American Archaeology, Seattle,
Wa.
View HTML version
Pierce, Christopher and Ann Ramenofsky
1998 Investigating Patterns of Conflict and Cooperation
during the Contact Period in New Mexico. Invited
presentation, Sixth Biennial Southwest Symposium, Hermosillo, Mexico.
Pierce, Christopher
1996 Why Corrugated Pottery? A Functional and Historical
Analysis of the Change from Smooth to Corrugated Cooking Pots in the
American Southwest. 61st Annual Meeting of the Society for
American Archaeology, New Orleans, La.
Thurs, Margaret, Donna Glowacki and Christopher Pierce
1996 Pottery Production in the Sand Canyon Locality.
61st Annual Meeting of the Society for American Archaeology, New
Orleans, La.
Pierce, Christopher, Donna Glowacki and Margaret Thurs
1996 Pottery Production and Distribution in the Sand Canyon
Locality. Fifth Biennial Southwest Symposium, Tempe, Az.
Pierce, Christopher
1995 Recent Research on Pueblo III Pottery Production and
Distribution in the Mesa Verde Region. Southwestern Pottery
Workshop, Crow Canyon Archaeological Center, Co.
Pierce, Christopher
1995 Why Corrugated Pottery? Uniting History and Function
through an Evolutionary Approach to Explaining Technological Change.
Invited presentation, Durango Conference on Southwest Archaeology,
Durango, Co.
Pierce, Christopher, Karan Adams and Joe Stewart
1994 Determining the Taxonomic Identity of Trees and Shrubs
Present in Prehistoric Hearth Ash Via ICP-AES Analysis. 59th
Annual Meeting of the Society for American Archaeology, Anaheim, Ca.
Pierce, Christopher
1994 Summary of the 1994 Southwest Pottery Workshop Held at
Crow Canyon Archaeological Center. Pottery Southwest
21(2): 8-9.
Pierce, Christopher
1994 Variation in Direct Evidence of Pottery Production among
Pueblo III Settlements in the Sand Canyon Locality. Pecos
Conference, Mesa Verde National Park, Co.
Pierce, Christopher
1993 Evolutionary Theory and the Explanation of Formal
Variation: An Application to Poverty Point Objects from the Lower
Mississippi Valley. Unpublished MA paper, Department of
Anthropology, University of Washington, Seattle.
Pierce, Christopher
1992 Effects of Pocket Gopher Burrowing on Archaeological
Deposits: A Simulation Approach. Geoarchaeology
7(3): 185-208.
View/hide abstract - view HTML version - Download PDF reprint
Abstract
The construction of burrows and movement of sediment by pocket gophers alter archaeological deposits by causing vertical size-sorting of artifacts, destruction of fragile artifacts, disruption of sedimentary structures, and organic enrichment of the subsurface. To evaluate the long-term effects of exposure to burrowing, a simulation was developed based on quantitative information on pocket gopher burrows and rates of sediment movement. Simulation results indicate the development of a distinct stone zone composed predominantly of particles greater than 6 cm after 4000-5000 years, and a logarithmic pattern to the rate of strata disruption. The patterns produced by the simulation compare well with patterns exhibited by actual archaeological deposits belonging to California's Milling Stone Horizon. These results suggest that current notions concerning the Milling Stone Horizon and other aspects of California prehistory may require revision, and that more emphasis must be placed on formation process research in such settings.
Pierce, Christopher
1991 Distinguishing Style and Function in Poverty Point
Objects. 56th Annual Meeting of the Society for American
Archaeology, New Orleans, La.
Pierce, Christopher
1989 Report on 1989 Archaeological Investigations of the
Buffalo Slough Tract, Dunklin County, Missouri. Submitted to
R. C. Dunnell for the Little River Lowlands Project, Department of
Anthropology, University of Washington, Seattle.
Pierce, Christopher
1989 A Critique
of Middle-Range Theory in Archaeology. Available at http://clevelandclinic.academia.edu/ChristopherPierce/Papers/1728686/A_Critique_of_Middle-Range_Theory_In_Archaeology and http://www.archive.org/details/ACritiqueOfMiddle-rangeTheoryInArchaeology
View/hide abstract - view HTML version - Download PDF reprint
Abstract
For the past decade, several archaeologists have advocated the development of middle-range theory as a way to give objective meaning to the archaeological record (e.g., Bettinger 1987; Binford 1977, 1983b; Thomas 1983, 1989; Torrence 1986). They argue that we must translate the static archaeological record into behaviorally dynamic terms by documenting causal linkages between relevant behaviors and their static material by-products. This is accomplished, they argue, by making observations today that establish signature patterns allowing the unambiguous recognition of particular dynamics from their static by-products, and inferring past dynamics from identification of signature patterns in the archaeological record. Further, it has been emphasized that the operations and products of middle-range theory must remain logically independent of the general theory we use to explain the past to avoid automatically confirming our ideas about the past through a tautology. This approach to middle-range research is flawed in two major respects. First, the justification of inferences relies on the establishment of universal behavioral laws and unambiguous signature patterns to validate the use of uniformitarian assumptions, neither of which can be accomplished in the manner proposed. Second, the tautological relationship between description and explanation is not only an unavoidable, but also a necessary aspect of science. Solutions to these problems lie in using the physical characteristics of the archaeological record itself as our source of knowledge about the past rather than translating the record into untestable behavioral reconstructions.
Livingston, Stephanie and Christopher Pierce
1989 Prehistoric Archaeology of the West Sinter Quarry,
Cortez Mountains, Nevada. Technical Report No. 61. Quaternary
Sciences Center, Desert Research Institute, Reno, Nv.
Durand, Stephen, Christopher Pierce and Stephanie Livingston
1989 The West Sinter Quarry Pits. In Prehistoric
Archaeology of the West Sinter Quarry, Cortez Mountains, Nevada, by S.
D. Livingston and C. Pierce, pp. 85-106. Technical Report No. 61.
Quaternary Sciences Center, Desert Research Institute, Reno, Nv.
Chapin, Nicholas, Christopher Pierce and Stephanie Livingston
1989 The West Sinter Rockshelter. In Prehistoric
Archaeology of the West Sinter Quarry, Cortez Mountains, Nevada, by S.
D. Livingston and C. Pierce, pp. 107-120. Technical Report No. 61.
Quaternary Sciences Center, Desert Research Institute, Reno, Nv.
Pierce, Christopher
1989 Exploring Functional Variation in Fire-Altered Rocks.
54th Annual Meeting of the Society for American Archaeology, Atlanta,
Ga.
View HTML version
Pierce, Christopher
1988 Southwestern Archaic and the Oshara Tradition Type
Sites: A Progress Report. Submitted to the L.J. Skaggs and
Mary C. Skaggs Foundation, Oakland, Ca.
Pierce, Christopher
1988 Functional Analysis of Fire-Altered Rock Features.
Society for California Archaeology Annual Meeting, Redding, Ca.
Pierce, Christopher
1988 California's Milling Stone Horizon: Of Mice or Men?
53rd Annual Meeting of the Society for American Archaeology, Phoenix,
Az.
Irwin-Williams, Cynthia, Christopher Pierce, Stephen Durand
and Pat Hicks
1988 The Density Dependent Method: Measuring the
Archaeological Record in the Northern Southwest. American
Archeology 7(1):38-48.
View/hide abstract - Download PDF reprint
Abstract
The Density Dependent Method consists of a coordinated group of techniques that are designed to measure large- and small-scale spatial variability contained in the archaeological record. This is accomplished with a series of nested sampling schemes that focuses on the individual artifact or feature in its environmental context. The primary objective of this paper os to present the details of the density-dependent method as it was developed to deal with the Archaic hunter-gatherer record in the northern Southwest. The method facilitiates quantiative analyses of the relationships between artifact spatial distributions and the local and regional resource framework as defined by a landform environment classificaiton.
Pierce, Christopher and Stephen Durand
1988 Prehistoric Land-Use and Spatial Patterning in the
Mesilla Bolson. In Archaeological Resources of the
Santa Teresa Study Area, South-Central New Mexico, edited by
J. C. Ravesloot, pp. 235-252. Arizona State Museum, Tucson.
Pierce, Christopher
1988 A Functional Classification of Fire-Altered Rock
Features from CA-SBr-5381. In The Archaeology of
Tiefort Basin, Fort Irwin, San Bernardino County, California,
by K. McGuire and M. Hall. Far Western Anthropological Research Group,
Davis, Ca.
Pierce, Christopher and Nicholas Chapin
1987 Archaeological Investigations for the West Sinter
Project, Southern Cortez Mountains, Eureka County, Nevada.
Technical Report No. 54. Social Sciences Center, Desert Research
Institute, Reno, Nv.
Pierce, Christopher
1987 A Cultural Resources Survey of Three Mineral Exploration
Areas in the Cortez Mountains, Eureka County, Nevada.
Cultural Resources Report 87-5. Social Sciences Center, Desert Research
Institute, Reno, Nv.
Pierce, Christopher
1987 A Cultural Resources Survey of the Trinity Silver
Project, Pershing County, Nevada. Cultural Resources Report 87-4.
Social Sciences Center, Desert Research Institute, Reno.
Pierce, Christopher
1987 Archaeological Survey of Access Roads along Portions of
a Transmission Line from Dixie Valley, Nevada to Bishop, California.
Cultural Resources Report 87-3. Social Sciences Center, Desert Research
Institute, Reno, Nv.
Pierce, Christopher
1987 A Cultural Resources Reconnaissance of the Sagewood
Estates Subdivision, Southern Washoe County, Nevada. Cultural
Resources Report 87-1. Social Sciences Center, Desert Research
Institute, Reno, Nv.
Pierce, Christopher
1986 Analysis of Sites Excavated by the Anasazi Origins
Project, 1965 to 1969: A Progress Report on BNS 8205746.
Submitted to the National Science Foundation, Washington, D.C.
Irwin-Williams, Cynthia, Christopher Pierce and Stephen Durand
1985 Archaeological Units and Human Activities in the
Southwest Archaic. 50th Annual Meeting of the Society for
American Archaeology, Denver, Co.
Pierce, Christopher
1984 Analysis of Cooking Stones from a Late Period Chumash
Village. 49th Annual Meeting of the Society for American
Archaeology, Portland, Or.
Pierce, Christopher and Stephen Durand
1984 Analysis of Regional Survey Data. In The
Oshara Tradition: Archaic Hunter- Gatherer Adaptation in the Northern
Southwest: Progress Report, Phase I. Submitted to the National Science
Foundation, Washington, D.C.
Pierce, Christopher
1983 The Cooking Stones of Talepop: Evidence of Status
Related Differentiation in Chumash Subsistence. Society for
California Archaeology Annual Meeting, San Diego, Ca.
Pierce, Christopher and Stephen Durand
1983 Regional Survey. In Hunter-Gatherer Culture
Change and the Development of Sedentism in the Southwest U.S., Phase I
1981-1983: Progress Report. Submitted to the National Science
Foundation, Washington, D.C.
Pierce, Christopher
1982 Cultural Resources Reconnaissance of Two Linear Miles of
Water Line Right-of-Way near Nixon, Nevada. Cultural
Resources Report 82-1. Social Sciences Center, Desert Research
Institute, Reno, Nv.
Pierce, Christopher and Cynthia Irwin-Williams
1982 Archaeology Field Investigations: Regional Survey.
In Supplementary Information on Phase I Development: Progress Report on
Project Activities in 1982. Submitted to the National Science
Foundation, Washington, D.C.
Pierce, Christopher
1982 Data Recovery Procedures for Excavations. In Archaeological
Investigations at Talepop (LAN-229), compiled by C. D. King,
pp. 2.6-2.22. Office of Public Archaeology, University of California,
Santa Barbara.
Pierce, Christopher
1982 Stratigraphy, Features, and Site Formation. In
Archaeological Investigations at Talepop (LAN-229),
compiled by C. D. King, pp. 5.1-5.87. Office of Public Archaeology,
University of California, Santa Barbara.
Pierce, Christopher, Eric Clingen and Lynn Gamble
1982 Petrology of Chipped Stone Artifacts. In Archaeological
Investigations at Talepop (LAN-229), compiled by C. D. King,
pp. 7.1-7.8. Office of Public Archaeology, University of California,
Santa Barbara.
Pierce, Christopher
1982 Processes of Site Formation at Talepop (Ca-LAn-229).
Southwestern Anthropological Association Annual Meeting, Sacramento, Ca.
Pierce, Christopher
1982 An Analysis of Surface Artifact Assemblages in the
Arroyo Cuervo Region, New Mexico. Pecos Conference, Pecos
National Monument, NM.
Pierce, Christopher
1980 Analysis of Shellfish Remains. In:
Investigations of the Escalante Site Ca-SCl-314. Ms. on file,
Department of Anthropology, San Jose State University, San Jose, Ca.
Hammett, Julia and Christopher Pierce
1979 Assessment of Cultural Resources at Lands of Hellett et
al: San Jose, California. Ms. on file, Archaeological
Regional Research Center and Clearinghouse, Cabrillo College, Aptos, Ca.
Dallas, Herb and Christopher Pierce
1979 Identifying Archaeological Features through Soil pH
Analysis at Ca-SCl-300. In: The Archaeology of
North 1st Street, edited by R. Cartier. Occasional Papers of
Archaeological Resource Management, San Jose, Ca.
Pierce, Christopher
1978 The Soil Chemistry of Ca-SCr-168. In: Secondary,
Subsurface Archaeological Evaluation of Ca-SCr-168, edited by
R. Cartier. Occasional Papers of Archaeological Resource Management,
San Jose, Ca.
Pierce, Christopher and Joseph Winter
1977 Hov 652 - 5MT4093. In: Hovenweep
1976: Archaeological Report No. 3, by J. C. Winter, pp.
57-61. San Jose State University, San Jose, Ca.
Pierce, Christopher and Bradley Noisat
1976 Water Control Experimentation. In Hovenweep
1975: Archaeological Report No. 2, by J. C. Winter, pp.
191-196. San Jose State University, San Jose, Ca.